Compare small business health insurance and benefits

Compare benefits brokers, group health insurers and HRA administrators, then see the federal rules and how a PEO plan compares with buying your own.

Benefits brokers, health insurers and HRA administrators

A benefits broker shops plans across insurers for you; ask how they are paid. Group health insurers sell plans directly or through a broker. HRA administrators run QSEHRA and ICHRA programs. Availability varies by state. Tick the ones you want quotes from, then press Request quotes.

14 shown

NABIP Find an Agent

Benefits broker

Free local search

Find licensed health insurance and benefits professionals near you by ZIP code, practice area or certification. Source

OneDigital

Benefits broker

Contact for a review

Small Business Essentials team for small and midsized employers: health plans, benefits administration and HR support. Source

Gallagher Benefit Services

Benefits broker

Contact the broker

Most disclosed benefits broker compensation from 2015 to 2024 ($2.96 billion). Source

Mercer Health and Benefits

Benefits broker

Contact the broker

Second in disclosed benefits broker compensation from 2015 to 2024 ($2.84 billion). Source

Lockton

Benefits broker

Contact the broker

Third from 2015 to 2024 ($2.76 billion) and first for 2024 alone. Source

Marsh McLennan Agency

Benefits broker

Contact the broker

Fourth in disclosed benefits broker compensation from 2015 to 2024 ($2.23 billion). Source

USI Insurance Services

Benefits broker

Contact the broker

Fifth in disclosed benefits broker compensation from 2015 to 2024 ($1.78 billion). Source

UnitedHealthcare

Group health insurer

Quote from the insurer or a broker

Small business medical, dental, vision and disability plans, including SHOP plans. Source

Aetna

Group health insurer

Quote from the insurer or a broker

Small group plans for 200 or fewer employees, including the level-funded Aetna Funding Advantage. Source

Blue Cross Blue Shield

Group health insurer

Through your local BCBS company

Local companies that together cover 1 in 3 Americans. Find yours by ZIP code. Source

Cigna Healthcare

Group health insurer

Quote from the insurer or a broker

Targets businesses with about 25 to 99 employees; 2 to 50 employee small group plans are limited. Source

Kaiser Permanente

Group health insurer

Quote from Kaiser or a broker

Small business plans in California, Colorado, Georgia, Hawaii, the Mid-Atlantic, Oregon and Washington. Source

PeopleKeep

HRA administrator

$25 per employee/month + $50 base

Administers QSEHRA and ICHRA; minimum three seats. Source

Take Command

HRA administrator

From $20 per employee/month + $40 platform fee

ICHRA and QSEHRA administration; pricing shown is for 1 to 49 employees. Source

Listed for comparison only, not an endorsement. Prices change, so confirm on each company's site.

Your options

OptionHow it worksOften fits
Small-group planYou buy a group policy from an insurer, usually through a licensed broker or agent.Teams that want to choose their own carrier and plan design. Working with a broker
SHOP Marketplace planGroup coverage bought through the Small Business Health Options Program.Employers that want the small business tax credit, which generally requires SHOP coverage.
PEO planYour employees join the PEO's pooled plans as part of co-employment.Small teams that also want payroll, HR and compliance help. PEO vs your own plan
QSEHRAYou reimburse employees tax-free for individual coverage they buy, up to IRS limits.Employers under 50 full-time employees that do not offer a group plan.
ICHRA (CHOICE arrangement)You reimburse individual coverage by employee class, with no federal minimum or maximum.Employers of any size that want a fixed budget per employee class.

Federal rules by size

The small business health care tax credit

The IRS lists these requirements:

The credit is up to 50% of premiums paid (35% for tax-exempt employers) and is available for two consecutive tax years. Ask your tax professional whether you qualify. See taxes and CPAs.

QSEHRA and ICHRA

QSEHRA: for employers with fewer than 50 full-time employees that do not offer a group health plan. It must be offered on the same terms to all full-time employees, can vary only by age and family size, and is capped at $6,450 self-only and $13,100 family for 2026. Employees need qualifying coverage to use it, and you must give written notice 90 days before each plan year.

ICHRA (CHOICE arrangement): available to employers of any size. Employees need individual coverage such as a Marketplace plan. There is no federal minimum or maximum, amounts must be the same within an employee class (varying only by age and dependents), and you cannot offer the same class a choice between a group plan and the arrangement.

How to compare

  1. Get a PEO quote that separates health premiums from the admin fee: how to compare PEO quotes.
  2. Get a small-group quote for similar plans from a licensed broker.
  3. Compare employee cost, networks where your people live, and renewal terms.

Compare benefits through PEOsSchedule a discovery call

Questions

Do small businesses have to offer health insurance?

Not under the federal employer mandate. The IRS employer shared responsibility rules apply to applicable large employers, generally those with 50 or more full-time employees including full-time equivalents.

What is the small business health care tax credit?

A federal credit of up to 50% of premiums (35% for tax-exempt employers) for employers with fewer than 25 full-time equivalents and below-limit average wages that pay at least half of employee-only premiums for a plan bought through the SHOP Marketplace. It can be claimed for two consecutive years.

What is a QSEHRA?

A qualified small employer health reimbursement arrangement lets employers with fewer than 50 full-time employees that do not offer a group plan reimburse employees tax-free for individual coverage, up to IRS limits ($6,450 self-only and $13,100 family for 2026).

Can a PEO get me better health benefits?

Sometimes. A PEO pools employees from many clients into its own plans. Compare a PEO quote with a quote for a group plan from a licensed broker to see which is better for your team.

Sources

General information, not legal, tax, insurance or financial advice. Rules change, so confirm with the agency or a licensed professional.