Compare payroll companies

Payroll providers and their published prices side by side, then what running payroll involves, the federal deadlines, and when a PEO makes more sense.

Payroll companies

Published prices are each company's monthly base fee plus a per-person fee, before add-ons. Quote-only providers price by headcount and features. Tick the ones you want quotes from, then press Request quotes.

9 shown

Gusto

Published pricing

From $49/month + $6 per person

Simple plan starting price per Gusto's comparison page. Source

OnPay

Published pricing

$49/month + $6 per person

One plan; the first month is offered free. Source

QuickBooks Payroll

Published pricing

$50/month + $6.50 per employee

Plan price shown on Intuit's payroll page; promotions vary. Works alongside QuickBooks accounting. Source

Square Payroll

Published pricing

$35/month + $6 per person

Full-service plan. A contractor-only plan is $6 per person paid. Source

Patriot Software

Published pricing

Full Service $37/month + $5 per worker

Basic plan without tax filing is $17/month + $4 per worker. Source

SurePayroll

Published pricing

Full Service from $29/month + $7 per employee

A Paychex company. Its pricing page shows more than one base price, so confirm the current offer. Source

ADP RUN

Quote only

Quote only

Four packages, from Essential Payroll to HR Pro. Source

Paychex Flex

Quote only

Quote only

Basic, Foundations, Advanced and Complete plans. Source

Rippling

Quote only

Quote only for payroll

Rippling says its plans start at $8 per employee per month plus a base fee; payroll pricing depends on headcount and products. Source

Listed for comparison only, not an endorsement. Prices change, so confirm on each company's site.

What payroll involves

Federal deadlines

ItemWhen
Form 941 (quarterly)April 30, July 31, October 31, January 31 (10 more days if deposits were on time)
Form 940 (FUTA, annual)January 31 (10 more days if deposits were on time)
Forms W-2 and W-3January 31, to employees and the SSA
Deposits, monthly schedule15th of the following month
Deposits, semiweekly scheduleWednesday to Friday paydays: next Wednesday. Saturday to Tuesday paydays: next Friday.
$100,000 or more owed in a dayNext business day

If a date falls on a weekend or legal holiday, the next business day applies. Form 944 replaces 941 only if the IRS notifies you in writing.

Your options

Do it yourselfPayroll softwarePayroll servicePEO
Who calculates and filesYouSoftware, with your reviewThe serviceThe PEO, often under its own accounts
Who is the employerYouYouYouYou and the PEO (co-employment)
Group benefitsSeparateSeparate or add-onSeparate or add-onIncluded pooled plans
HR and compliance helpNoneLimitedVariesIncluded

Even when a provider files for you, you can remain responsible for the taxes. See who is responsible for payroll taxes.

How to choose

Compare payroll plus benefits through PEOsSchedule a discovery call

Questions

When is Form 941 due?

Quarterly, by the last day of the month after the quarter ends: April 30, July 31, October 31 and January 31. You get 10 more days if all deposits were made on time.

When are W-2s due?

By January 31, both to employees and to the Social Security Administration with Form W-3.

How often do I deposit payroll taxes?

Monthly or semiweekly, based on your lookback-period liability. Monthly depositors deposit by the 15th of the next month. Any day you owe $100,000 or more, deposit by the next business day.

Do I need a PEO just to run payroll?

No. Payroll software or a payroll service can handle it. A PEO also adds benefits, HR support and co-employment, which can be worth it if you want those too.

Sources

General information, not legal, tax, insurance or financial advice. Rules change, so confirm with the agency or a licensed professional.