PEO Health Insurance vs Buying Your Own Plan
How PEO master health policies differ from small-group plans you buy directly, and what to compare.
Access to better health plans is one of the main reasons small companies join a PEO. The alternative is buying a small-group plan directly from a carrier or through a broker. The two work differently.
How the two options differ
| PEO master policy | Small-group plan you buy | |
|---|---|---|
| Who holds the policy | The PEO sponsors plans that cover multiple client businesses under one policy. | Your company holds its own policy with the carrier. |
| Group size category | Often large-group plans, which are typically for employers above about 50 or 100 eligible employees depending on location. | Small-group plans for employers below that size. |
| How rates are set | Underwritten on the PEO's pooled group and reassessed at renewal. | Carrier-set premiums based on the regional or covered population, using age-banded, composite or community rating. |
| Life-event changes | Employees submit qualifying life events to the PEO for approval. | The employer reviews and approves them. |
| Billing | Premiums are remitted to the carrier through the PEO. | You pay the carrier directly, often by ACH. |
| Choice | You pick among the plans the PEO offers, and the carriers depend on your location. | You choose any plan available to you. |
Differences above are described by Justworks, one PEO, in its help center. Other PEOs structure plans differently.
Questions to ask a PEO about health benefits
- Which carriers and networks are offered in your state?
- Is the plan a master policy, and how is the renewal rate set?
- Are premiums billed separately from the PEO fee? At some providers they are, such as Justworks.
- How do contributions and eligibility rules work?
- What happens to deductibles if you leave mid-year? See switching PEOs.
More background in PEO health insurance for small business and what PEOs cost.
Compare PEO quotesSchedule a discovery call
Questions
Is PEO health insurance cheaper than buying my own?
Not always. A PEO can open large-group plans to a small company, but pricing depends on the PEO's pooled experience, your demographics and the plans offered. Compare a PEO quote with a quote from a broker for the same plan level.
What is the difference between large group and small group health insurance?
Large-group plans are generally for employers above roughly 50 or 100 benefits-eligible employees, depending on the state. Small-group plans are for smaller employers. Large-group rates are underwritten on the group's demographics and claims history and reassessed at renewal, while small-group premiums are set by the carrier for the broader region or covered population.
Can I keep my own health plan if I join a PEO?
Usually the PEO's benefits program is part of the service, so you choose among the plans it offers. Ask the PEO whether any exceptions exist.
What happens to my deductible if I leave a PEO?
Plan years and accumulators often reset when you change carriers or plans. Time a move for the renewal date where you can. See switching PEOs.
Sources
General information, not legal, tax, insurance or financial advice. Confirm details with the provider, your accountant, broker or attorney.