PEO options: how to choose the right setup

Your options depend on headcount, budget and how much HR help you want. Here is how the choices break down, with the providers that fit each.

Minimums and prices change, so confirm with each provider.

Option 1: Decide whether you need a PEO at all

OptionWhat it isBest when
PEOCo-employer that runs payroll, benefits, HR and compliance under a shared arrangement.You want group benefits, HR support and compliance in one service.
ASOOutsourced HR administration. You remain the sole employer.You want help without sharing the employer role.
Payroll and HR softwareSelf-serve tools with optional add-ons.You have in-house HR capacity and a simple benefits setup.

Weighing the trade-offs? Read PEO pros and cons and co-employment explained.

Option 2: Match the PEO to your headcount

Option 3: Choose a pricing model

Option 4: Choose by industry, state or need

See PEOs by industry and PEOs by state.

All PEO options at a glance

PEOPricing modelMinimumIRS CPEOESACBest for
JustworksPublished2 employeesYes, on the IRS listAccreditedSmall teams that want published pricing and a simple platform
TriNetQuote only5 employeesYes, on the IRS list—Companies in TriNet's core industries that want industry-specific packages
InsperityQuote only5 employeesYes, on the IRS list—Companies that want a dedicated HR account team
Paychex PEOQuote only5 employeesYes, on the IRS listAccreditedSmaller US businesses that want payroll and HR from one provider
ADP TotalSourceQuote only5 employeesYes, on the IRS list—Established mid-market companies
Rippling PEOQuote only5 employees—Reported not accreditedCompanies that want HR, IT and finance in one platform
Deel US PEOPublished (reported)———Companies already using Deel for international hiring
QuestcoQuote only—Yes, on the IRS list—Small and mid-sized businesses, including franchises, that want a Texas-based PEO
Oasis PEOQuote only5 employeesYes, on the IRS listAccreditedGrowing small and mid-sized businesses with fewer than 49 employees (Oasis Outsourcing, now part of Paychex)
CoAdvantageQuote only—Yes, on the IRS list—Companies that want a multi-state, multi-industry generalist PEO
Vensure Employer SolutionsQuote only———Companies hiring in new states or wanting group benefits through a multi-state PEO
G&A PartnersQuote only10 employees——Healthcare, skilled trades, manufacturing, nonprofit and professional services companies
Engage PEOQuote only—Yes, on the IRS listAccreditedSmall and mid-sized businesses without an internal HR team, including healthcare, restaurants, hotels and franchises
Sequoia OneQuote only—Yes, on the IRS list—Venture-backed tech startups that want advisory HR plus a People Platform
NextepQuote only—Yes, on the IRS list—Companies that want flat-fee, itemized PEO billing rather than a percentage of payroll
XcelHRQuote only1 employee—Reported not accreditedVery small employers, startups and manufacturers or government contractors that want broad benefits
AlphaStaffQuote only——AccreditedSmall businesses and franchises that need strong recruiting tools
BBSIQuote only———Construction, restaurant, hospitality, landscaping, manufacturing and trucking businesses, especially on the West Coast
ScalePEOQuote only———Small and mid-sized businesses that want one cloud platform for payroll, benefits, HR and compliance
Alcott HRQuote only—Yes, on the IRS list—Established small and mid-sized businesses in the New York metro area and Northeast

Questions

What are my options besides a PEO?

The main alternatives are an administrative services organization (ASO), payroll and HR software, or a payroll provider with separate benefits through a broker. A PEO is the only option where the provider is a co-employer and can offer its own group health plan.

What are the options for PEO pricing?

Providers charge a per-employee monthly fee, a percentage of payroll, or a flat fee, and some bill benefits and fees separately. Ask for an itemized quote so you can compare.

Can a very small business use a PEO?

Some can. In our data, Justworks, XcelHR list a minimum under five employees. Many others require five or more.

Which PEO option is cheapest?

It depends on headcount, state and benefits. Published pricing makes comparison easier, but total cost includes health premiums, workers' comp and onboarding fees.

Request quotesSee all PEO providers