AlphaStaff vs Paychex PEO
How the two PEOs compare on pricing, minimum employees and fit.
| AlphaStaff | Paychex PEO | |
|---|---|---|
| Company size | — | About 19,000 employees (Paychex, 2025) |
| Headquarters | Fort Lauderdale, FL | Rochester, NY |
| Founded | 1997 | 1971 |
| Pricing | Not published. Custom quote. | No published PEO pricing. Quote required. |
| Pricing model | Quote only | Quote only |
| Best for | Small businesses and franchises that need strong recruiting tools | Smaller US businesses that want payroll and HR from one provider |
| IRS certified (CPEO) | — | Yes, on the IRS list |
| ESAC accreditation | Accredited | Accredited |
| Minimum employees | — | 5 employees |
Carriers, 401(k) and workers' comp: side by side
| AlphaStaff | Paychex PEO | |
|---|---|---|
| 401(k) provider | AlphaStaff administers its own 401(k) plan | — |
| Workers' comp | Described as an A-rated carrier; not named | — |
| Other named partners | — | Paychex acquired Oasis Outsourcing in 2018; carrier and 401(k) details not named in sources reviewed |
We only list carriers and partners that a filing, the provider or a named review states. Lineups vary by state and change at renewal.
Questions to ask before you sign
- Which medical carriers and networks are available in my state and zip code?
- Are the health plans fully insured or partially self-funded, and who bears claims risk?
- Who is the 401(k) recordkeeper, and what are the total plan fees and match options?
- Who is the workers' comp carrier, how are rates set, and what happens to my experience rating if I leave?
- Is the entity that will employ my staff on the IRS CPEO list, and is it ESAC accredited?
- What renewal increase did your plans see in each of the last 3 years?
Choose AlphaStaff if
Small businesses and franchises that need strong recruiting tools.
- Built-in applicant tracking system (AlphaStaff Hiring) and recruiting experts
- ESAC accredited
- Custom report library and performance management support
Choose Paychex PEO if
Smaller US businesses that want payroll and HR from one provider.
- ESAC and IRS accredited
- Payroll account manager and HR generalist support
- Multi-state payroll
Ask AlphaStaff about
- Pricing is not published
- Interface appears outdated and the mobile app is limited
- Support is by phone and email on weekdays, with no live chat
- Minimum employees not stated in the source reviewed
Ask Paychex PEO about
- Five-employee minimum and a one-year contract reported
- Reported as weaker at larger scale
Frequently asked questions
Is AlphaStaff or Paychex PEO cheaper?
AlphaStaff: Not published. Custom quote. Paychex PEO: No published PEO pricing. Quote required. Published rates are not directly comparable to quote-only pricing, and health premiums are separate.
Which is better for a small company, AlphaStaff or Paychex PEO?
AlphaStaff is best for small businesses and franchises that need strong recruiting tools. Paychex PEO is best for smaller us businesses that want payroll and hr from one provider.
Based on third-party reviews and vendor pricing pages. See each provider page for sources.