Alcott HR vs Paychex PEO
How the two PEOs compare on pricing, minimum employees and fit.
| Alcott HR | Paychex PEO | |
|---|---|---|
| Company size | — | About 19,000 employees (Paychex, 2025) |
| Headquarters | Plainview, NY | Rochester, NY |
| Founded | — | 1971 |
| Pricing | Quote only. | No published PEO pricing. Quote required. |
| Pricing model | Quote only | Quote only |
| Best for | Established small and mid-sized businesses in the New York metro area and Northeast | Smaller US businesses that want payroll and HR from one provider |
| IRS certified (CPEO) | Yes, on the IRS list | Yes, on the IRS list |
| ESAC accreditation | — | Accredited |
| Minimum employees | — | 5 employees |
Carriers, 401(k) and workers' comp: side by side
| Alcott HR | Paychex PEO | |
|---|---|---|
| Other named partners | — | Paychex acquired Oasis Outsourcing in 2018; carrier and 401(k) details not named in sources reviewed |
We only list carriers and partners that a filing, the provider or a named review states. Lineups vary by state and change at renewal.
Questions to ask before you sign
- Which medical carriers and networks are available in my state and zip code?
- Are the health plans fully insured or partially self-funded, and who bears claims risk?
- Who is the 401(k) recordkeeper, and what are the total plan fees and match options?
- Who is the workers' comp carrier, how are rates set, and what happens to my experience rating if I leave?
- Is the entity that will employ my staff on the IRS CPEO list, and is it ESAC accredited?
- What renewal increase did your plans see in each of the last 3 years?
Choose Alcott HR if
Established small and mid-sized businesses in the New York metro area and Northeast.
- Full-service model covering HR administration, payroll, benefits, workers' compensation and compliance
- Headquartered in Plainview, New York
Choose Paychex PEO if
Smaller US businesses that want payroll and HR from one provider.
- ESAC and IRS accredited
- Payroll account manager and HR generalist support
- Multi-state payroll
Ask Alcott HR about
- No published minimum. One third-party article estimates at least five W-2 employees
- Northeast focus may not be cost-competitive elsewhere
- Bundled services may raise the effective minimum
Ask Paychex PEO about
- Five-employee minimum and a one-year contract reported
- Reported as weaker at larger scale
Frequently asked questions
Is Alcott HR or Paychex PEO cheaper?
Alcott HR: Quote only. Paychex PEO: No published PEO pricing. Quote required. Published rates are not directly comparable to quote-only pricing, and health premiums are separate.
Which is better for a small company, Alcott HR or Paychex PEO?
Alcott HR is best for established small and mid-sized businesses in the new york metro area and northeast. Paychex PEO is best for smaller us businesses that want payroll and hr from one provider.
Based on third-party reviews and vendor pricing pages. See each provider page for sources.