[email protected]Schedule a free discovery callBook a free call
Get quotes

ADP TotalSource vs AlphaStaff

How the two PEOs compare on pricing, minimum employees and fit.

ADP TotalSourceAlphaStaff
Company sizeAbout 67,000 employees (ADP, 2025)—
HeadquartersRoseland, NJFort Lauderdale, FL
Founded19491997
PricingNo published PEO pricing. Quote required.Not published. Custom quote.
Pricing modelQuote onlyQuote only
Best forEstablished mid-market companiesSmall businesses and franchises that need strong recruiting tools
IRS certified (CPEO)Yes, on the IRS list—
ESAC accreditation—Accredited
Minimum employees5 employees—

Carriers, 401(k) and workers' comp: side by side

ADP TotalSourceAlphaStaff
Health carriersMultiple carrier choices; carriers not named—
401(k) providerADP TotalSource Retirement Savings Plan, a multiple employer 401(k) with 23 funds, 6,500+ adopting employers, 348,000 participants and $9B+ in assets (Sept 30, 2024); total cost 0.26% to 1.01%. Materials are branded Voya, which suggests Voya as recordkeeper (inferred, not stated) Sept 30, 2024AlphaStaff administers its own 401(k) plan
Workers' compWorkers' comp insurance with claims support, safety support and 24/7 nurse triage; carrier not namedDescribed as an A-rated carrier; not named

We only list carriers and partners that a filing, the provider or a named review states. Lineups vary by state and change at renewal.

Questions to ask before you sign

Choose ADP TotalSource if

Established mid-market companies.

  • Large scale with more than half a million worksite employees reported
  • Broad HR, payroll and benefits administration

Choose AlphaStaff if

Small businesses and franchises that need strong recruiting tools.

  • Built-in applicant tracking system (AlphaStaff Hiring) and recruiting experts
  • ESAC accredited
  • Custom report library and performance management support

Ask ADP TotalSource about

  • Pricing is not published
  • Cost structure is reported as better suited to larger teams

Ask AlphaStaff about

  • Pricing is not published
  • Interface appears outdated and the mobile app is limited
  • Support is by phone and email on weekdays, with no live chat
  • Minimum employees not stated in the source reviewed

Frequently asked questions

Is ADP TotalSource or AlphaStaff cheaper?

ADP TotalSource: No published PEO pricing. Quote required. AlphaStaff: Not published. Custom quote. Published rates are not directly comparable to quote-only pricing, and health premiums are separate.

Which is better for a small company, ADP TotalSource or AlphaStaff?

ADP TotalSource is best for established mid-market companies. AlphaStaff is best for small businesses and franchises that need strong recruiting tools.

Based on third-party reviews and vendor pricing pages. See each provider page for sources.

Get matched quotes